Posted at 11:11
AM ET, 08/13/2012
On
social issues, there's no daylight between Ryan and the far right
By Jamelle
Bouie
For the right wing, Paul Ryan is
the perfect representation of their budgetary priorities — low spending on
social services, high spending on defense and the slow unraveling of
entitlements for younger Americans. What goes under the radar, however, is his
commitment to right-wing cultural values, which is just as strong as his
disdain for the welfare state.
On abortion, Ryan is in the far-right
of his party. As Michelle Goldberg explains for the
Daily Beast, he doesn’t believe that women have any right to terminate a
pregnancy, even if the circumstances are dire. To wit, he co-sponsored
the Sanctity of Life Act,
which declares that a fertilized egg “shall have all the legal and
constitutional attributes and privileges of personhood.” It would criminalize
all abortion, as well as in vitro fertilization and some forms of birth
control. Indeed, it stands as one of the most extreme anti-abortion measures
currently floating in Congress.
On gay
rights, he’s just as reactionary. He supports amending the Constitution to ban
same-sex marriage, and voted for the
Federal Marriage Amendment in 2004 and 2006. He supports the Defense of
Marriage Act and in 2003, approved of a bill that
would prevent federal courts from considering DOMA and possibly overturning it.
He voted in 1999 to keep same-sex couples from adopting in the District of
Columbia, he opposed last year’s effort to repeal Don’t Ask, Don’t Tell and
when the Matthew Shepard and James Byrd, Jr. Hate Crimes Prevention Act came up
for a vote in 2009, Ryan placed his name in opposition. At most, he supported the 2007 version of the
Employment Non-Discrimination Act, which would have prohibited discrimination
on the basis of sexual orientation.
The Human Rights Campaign, an
LGBT rights organization, gave Ryan a 0 percent rating on its score card in
2006. Likewise, the ACLU gave him a 13 percent rating on civil rights when they
evaluated his record in 2002.
Ryan receives credit, from all
sides, for being a “principled” opponent of government. That’s only partially
true. When we need to deal with market failures and provide security for the
least well-off, Paul Ryan is a dedicated libertarian. But when it comes to
women’s bodily autonomy or the rights of same-sex couples, Ryan is happy to
enforce his views with the power of the state.
Jamelle Bouie is a staff writer
at The American
Prospect. You can find his blog here.
No comments:
Post a Comment